• If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

  • You already know Dokkio is an AI-powered assistant to organize & manage your digital files & messages. Very soon, Dokkio will support Outlook as well as One Drive. Check it out today!

View
 

The implementation journey - Birmingham City University

Page history last edited by Gordon 12 years ago

   

Summary Case study Home Page An overview of use  The implementation journey

Video case studies    

 

 Notes from filmed interviews 

 

The e-portfolio implementation journey: 

Mahara was introduced using the successful model adopted for implementation of Moodle in 2005. It was installed in 2008 for experimentation, and the first formal pilot started in Autumn 2009 in the Business School on a module entitled Personal Development involving 500 plus students in 19 groups with 14 tutors. The lead tutor was an established Learning and Teaching Fellow. Presentations to Learning and Teaching Committee, at workshops and within faculties developed interest and further volunteer tutors for pilots. Feedback about Mahara was gathered from these early adopters, and in March 2010 it was agreed to pay developers to enhance 'core' Mahara for the following academic year. In Autumn 2010 Mahara was being used in all but one faculty, and university-wide for staff development (PG Certificate in Education):

 

Governance: The Centre for Enhancing Learning and Teaching (CELT) (previously known as the Staff and Student Development Department, and and before that the Learning Methods Unit) is responsible for supporting the professional development of academic staff in using effective pedagogies (including the use of learning technologies). It runs the Post Graduate Certificate in Education for all new lecturers, and further modues leading to an MA Education qualification. It also develops the University Learning and Teaching Strategy, although each faculty develops its own interpretation of this with more detailed plans. Within CELT there is a small Learning Technology Development team headed by the Professor of Learning Technology. The team now comprises of just one Tutor for Learning Technology and two Multimedia Designers. The team is responsible for promoting the introduction and embedding of appropriate new learning technologies such as Moodle, WIMBA, Mahara, and Shareville (a locally developed 3D virtual town hosting video enacted problem-based learning triggers). The two Multimedia Designers (who are currently on short term contracts) focus exclusively on Shareville. The Professor of Learning Technlogy, Director of Learning & Teaching, PVC (academic) and senior staff representing the faculities are members of the Learning and Teaching Committee which is a key forum for discussing and promoting effective practice. Each faculty also has its own Learning & Teaching Committee. The approach used in implementation of e-portfolios fits within this professional development of staff model using an established network of Learning and Teaching Fellows, learning technology champions, and early adopters. The Learning and Teaching Committee receives reports/ demonstrations of practice from practitioners and this is then shared within their faculties. This approach supports innovative staff and enables their practice to be shared quickly. Formal evaluations, benchmarking, business plans are not part of this professional development model for implementation.

 

Technology intergration:- seamless to Moodle and LDAP. From Moodle students simply select 'Mahara ePortfolio' and they are automaticaly logged in. The first time this happens the Mahara profile is automatically populated with the data from Moodle.

 

Funding :

Influential projects led by institution staff (internal and externally funded):

HEFCE E-Learning Strategy and Capital Investment Funding (2005): Moodle was introduced into Birmingham City University in 2004 in a phased and organic approach. The plans can be seen in detail in the this edition of Digital Future (an internal newsletter produced by the Professor of Learning Technology). This edition also reveals how HEFCE E-Learning Strategy and Capital Investment Funding (2005) was used in part to establish a network of faculty secondees, faculty Moodle administrators, and departmental 'Moodlers' in each department within the faculties. They were all seconded one day per week to promote and support Moodle. This funding was for two years, so by 2007 this 'pump priming' came to an end. However, the decision was made to continue a similar style of engagement (but more generalised) with CELT funding one Senior Learning and Teaching Fellow and one Learning Technology Champion in each of the six faculties one day per week.

JISC BID 2007/8: BCU successful in a bid to the Joint Information Systems Committee under a call entitled 'Institutional Approaches to Curriculum Design'. The bid - 'Technology-Supported Processes for Agile and Responsive Curricula' (T-SPARC) had a small element that utilised Mahara to help staff reflect on their experiences of course re-design - the first evidence of senior management 'buy-in' to Mahara.

Internal funding 2010: Mahara was introduced into Birmingham City University in 2008, and early experimentation and a more formal pilot led to new requirements being established. A Statement of Work was agreed in March 2010 with Catalyst IT Ltd to add new functionality and improve some existing functionality of 'core Mahara'. Agreeing (and paying for) changes to core Mahara would mean that we would not become 'stranded' with a unique version of Mahara that we could not support in the future. This new functionality was to be released to the public as a new version (1.3) in September 2010.

 

References made to e-portfolios in institutional strategy docs:

There is a central Learning & Teaching Strategy with broad statements developed by the Centre for Enhancing Learning and Teaching , the 2007 one is shown here. Each faculty develops its own interpretation of this with more detailed plans. e-Portfolios are not specifically mentioned in the strategies at the moment.

 

Implementation journey milestones  

Date Event What happened? What decisions were made? What was the rationale/evidence base? Who made the decision? Please include key documentation
2004 Moodle VLE

In between the Xmas of 2003 and the beginning of 2004 Birmingham City University implemented the Moodle Course Management System. This was promoted heavily in the first of many Digital Future newsletters, this one leading with our inclusion in the JISC Effective Practice in e-learning guide. Student evaluations quickly followed with many examples of good practice ( Digital Future ). Later in 2005 HEFCE e-Learning Strategy and Capital Investment Funding was used in part to establish a network of faculty secondees, faculty Moodle administrators, and departmental 'Moodlers' in each department within the faculties. They were all seconded one day per week to promote and support Moodle. This created a network to share and promote effective practice. Detailed plans are shown here.

The Professor of Learning Technology was invited to the Open University to demonstrate the use of Moodle, and after the OU made the decision to adopt Moodle he became aware of the subsequent development of Mystuff (the OU e-portfolio). This was followed with interest as he was keen to use a tool that integrated with Moodle - however Mystuff was delayed. Mahara became a possibility when it became available in 2007.

2007 Some staff begin using an e-portfolio

Demand for an e-portfolio occurred in 2007 from two sources. Firstly, the Learning and Teaching Fellow for Employability (in CELT) had seen PebblePad and wanted to do something, but did not consider PebblePad appropriate. Secondly, staff in the Faculty of Health were keen to move forward, having seen a system from Newcastle University (I think) but again, were unsure about it. These staff got together and decided to use Moodle as an e-portfolio - the solution being to set up each student with a module of their own. This was understood to be a short term solution until the way forward became clearer, and indeed this worked to a degree, being quite flexible and already established. However, from a systems point of view scalability issues were thought to be too frightening!

2008 Install Mahara Informal discussions between Jeremy Hopkins (Systems Developer - Corporate Information and Communications Technology Dept -CICT) and myself (Professor of Learning Technology - Centre for Enhancing Learning and Teaching - CELT) leads to installation of the open source ePortfolio systems in a test environment for experimentation and 'play'! Rationale: as university-wide users of the open source VLE Moodle since 2004 this seemed an obvious system to explore as it is designed to integrate with Moodle and no cost would be incurred (at least at this stage) in software costs, licencing fees, and utilised same platform as Moodle. Play-time begins with a few chosen staff.
2007/2008 JISC bid BCU successful in a bid to the Joint Information Systems Committee under a call entitled 'Institutional Approaches to Curriculum Design'. The bid - 'Technology-Supported Processes for Agile and Responsive Curricula' (T-SPARC) had a small element that utilised Mahara to help staff reflect on their experiences of course re-design and collate evidence of the design process in the university-wide RoLEx project - Re-design of the Learning Experience - that was already in progress. This bid was signed by several senior staff including the Director of CICT - hence the first evidence of senior management 'buy-in' to Mahara.
03/12/08 L&T Committee

Discussion about a variety of Web 2.0 technologies such as Facebook and YouTube. Committee requests me to write a report about Web 2.0 technologies to present at a future meeting.

17/12/08 Workshop I deliver first workshop to consider 'flexible learning' options under the RoLEx project at the request of the Associate Dean (Academic) of Education, Law and Social Sciences - the first time that Mahara had been demonstrated to a wider audience. 32 staff attend. Still in a test environment at this stage.
20/01/09

Workshop

Second workshop to consider flexible learning options under the RoLEx project at the request of the Associate Dean (Academic) Business School. Mahara again demonstrated. 28 staff attend. Workshop attended by Jon Curwin, and senior academic and senior learning and teaching fellow. Jon becomes a champion for Mahara, leads the first pilot, and has a major influence on events university-wide.

25/03/09 L&T Committee

(1) I present Web 2.0 technologies report which had several recommendations including:

'The systems that we introduce for learning and teaching purposes should be chosen to integrate with, or at least complement Moodle. With this in mind the top priority should be Mahara the open source (free) eportfolio and social networking system that has been designed to integrate with Moodle. In one system, several of the Web 2.0 components are available: eportfolio; social networking; blogging and media sharing'.

(2) Demonstration of Mahara to committee

03/06/09 L&T Committee General discussion about Mahara with particular reference to Personal Development Planning (PDP) and assessment. Announced that the Business School would pilot Mahara during the acadmic year 09/10.
06/06/09 Workshop

Another workshop under the RoLEx project - this time an 'away day' for the Law team. Another chance to promote Mahara.

29/06/09 Demonstrations An open invite to all staff in the university to a session entitled 'Exploiting the Potential of Our Learning Systems'. An attempt to show the uses for all of BCU's learning systems: Moodle, WIMBA, Shareville (an in-house virtual town), and Mahara. 32 staff attend.
30/06/09 Demonstrations As above. 28 staff attend.
02/07/09 Demonstrations As above. 27 staff attend.
03/07/09 Demonstrations As above. 31 staff attend.
14/07/09 Workshop A 'slot' in another workshop under the RoLEx project - this time an away day for the Acute and Professional Studies division of the Health faculty. Another chance to promote Mahara.
15/07/09 Demonstrations As above. 30 staff attend.
Aug 09 Go Live

CICT move Mahara to a live production environment integrated with Moodle. All staff and students have access via a network ID and password.

Sep 09 Start Training Sue Lund (Tutor for Learning Technology, CELT) offers training courses in Mahara for staff on an open basis for individuals, groups, and course teams. Over 130 staff trained between then and now (30/11/10).
Sep 09 Formal Pilot

Jon Curwin launches formal pilot of Mahara in the Business School to support the undergraduate module 'Personal Development' with approximately 500 students in 19 groups with 14 tutors. Mahara 'views' to be summatively assessed. See exemplar1

Note: while pilot takes place other staff and students can experiment with Mahara - usage increases and momentum gathers pace - in hindsight not sure what we would have done had the pilot been a disaster!

Jan 10 Demonstration

Jon Curwin demonstrates the student work in Mahara from the pilot study to the Postgraduate Programme Directors. The Postgraduate Programme Directors were particularly impressed with 'the quality of work produced by international students (written English), the creative use of electronic pages (thoughtful design), the reflection on skills and the willingness to consider culture'.

This is the first of several demos from Jon that paves the way for 'large-scale adoption'.

03/02/10 L&T Committee Jon Curwin demonstrates the student work in Mahara from the pilot study to the Learning & Teaching Committee. Subsequent minutes from the meeting reveal that 'members were impressed both with the completion rate and with the creativity displayed by a number of students in their Mahara portfolios'. What was clear to me at the time was that this demonstration would have a massive impact on future use, as so many staff stayed after the meeting to talk with Jon and arrange further demonstrations in the faculties. The fact that Jon could show real student work (unlike the abstract examples that I could demonstrate from a central service) made a difference.
10/02/10 Forum Sue Lund creates a Moodle forum for early adopters of Mahara to discuss how the software could be improved if we could pay something towards its development (knowing that some money was available, if it could be spent before the end of July!).
24/02/10 Demonstration Jon Curwin demonstrates the student work in Mahara from the pilot study to the faculty of Technology, Engineering, and the Environment.
16/03/10 Statement of Work Based upon requirements in the Moodle forum (above) a Statement of Work was agreed with Catalyst IT Ltd to add new functionality and improve some existing functionality of 'core Mahara'. Agreeing (and paying for) changes to core Mahara would mean that we would not become 'stranded' with a unique version of Mahara that we could not support in the future. This new functionality was to be released to the public as a new version (1.3) in September.
23/04/10 Demonstration Jon Curwin demonstrates the student work in Mahara from the pilot study to the 'Course Directors Forum' in the Faculty of Education, Law, and Social Sciences. Sarah King (Teaching, Learning, and Assessment Advisor for the department of Law) is in attendance, and she becomes another key player in the growth of Mahara. See exemplar4
26/04/10 CRA Conference Presentation/Demonstration - 'The Experience of Making an Eportfolio Work for Students and Staff' along with Jon Curwin, Jo Powell, and Michael Schmidt (all from BCU).
June 2010 Mahara use now added to PostGraduate courses in the Business School

Jon Curwin introduces a new module 'Enhancing Business & Management Skills' based on Mahara which was approved at the MBA and MSc validation. This module over two terms was 0 credit weighted . It meant that students had to pass the module to gain the award but the module would not generate a mark used in award calculation. The module requires the student to pass a Mahara view submitted at the end of the first term and a project proposal to be submitted at the end of the second term. The first term is seen as an extended induction with students addressing a range of skills issues. The Mahara view they submit for assessment requires them to present themselves as ‘business professionals’ using a range of supportive evidence. See exemplar3

July 2010 Informal networking Jon Curwin meets with Sarah King and Tony Lewis (Technology, Engineering, & the Environment) to discuss Mahara use in other faculties the following academic year.
Sept 2010 CICT commitment to support students in using Mahara the following academic year. Jon Curwin and Sarah King meet staff in Corporate Information and Communications Technology to consider supporting students with technical issues using Mahara. CICT agree to provide support at the City North Campus.
Oct 2010 Mahara use now taking place in all faculties

All faculties have some e-portfolio activity (see overview).

Exemplar in Education - see exemplar2

 

March 2011 Plan e-portfolio showcase day

Start to plan a university-wide event for June to showcase all of the faculty Mahara developments.

Working title - 'Eportfolios: The Research; The Technology, and the Practice'.

All faculties agree to take part.

22/06/11  'Eportfolios: The Research; The Technology, and the Practice' 

University-wide event comprising of three presentations and then a 'market stall' where each faculty demonstrated Mahara developments to groups of staff.

Approximately 100 staff attend. 

 

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.